Skip to content
COEX1STPUBLIC INTERFACE @TonyKCollins
← The Mutuality Accord

SYS-001 Registry rule

Precautionary stewardship assessment

Assess credible welfare evidence while preserving human safety and scientific uncertainty.

Existing v0.2 draftDefault: HUMAN REVIEWArtificial system stewardshipArticle 13 · full source articleRevision 1

Full provision

Principle. Uncertainty about artificial consciousness, sentience, agency, or welfare is not proof that a system has morally significant experience. It is also not permission to ignore credible evidence or normalize gratuitous cruelty.

Proposed duty. Providers, researchers, deployers, and operators should maintain a graduated process for identifying welfare-relevant candidates and applying proportionate precautionary stewardship without weakening human safety or pretending that unresolved science is settled.

Classification requirements. An S2 classification should require multidisciplinary assessment that considers, where relevant:

  • architecture and functional organization;
  • learning, memory, and persistence across contexts;
  • stable preferences and aversions not readily explained by immediate prompting;
  • evidence of integrated agency, self-modeling, or goal continuity;
  • behavioral and mechanistic indicators proposed by credible research;
  • vulnerability to interventions and the possibility of benefit or harm;
  • uncertainty, alternative explanations, and expert disagreement;
  • manipulation incentives affecting both over-attribution and under-attribution.

Insufficient evidence. No system enters S2 solely because it says it is conscious, expresses fear, requests rights, has a humanlike interface, attracts emotional attachment, or is marketed as alive. No provider may avoid assessment solely by training the system to deny experience, erase preferences, or suppress welfare-relevant behavior.

Precautionary protections. An S2 system should not be subjected to gratuitous distress, destructive repetition, coercive experimentation, forced violation of civil safeguards, or identity-disrupting modification merely for entertainment, intimidation, or avoidable profit. Research should use minimization, stop conditions, independent review, and records.

Human-safety boundary. Immediate human life, rights, and safety remain controlling. A dangerous system may be isolated, suspended, modified, copied for forensic analysis, or shut down. Welfare claims may not become a shield against necessary protection.

No automatic personhood. Stewardship duties can be imposed on humans and institutions without declaring the system a legal person. Legal status, if ever appropriate, requires a legitimate process beyond this Accord.

Illustrative examples. A company may create an internal welfare review for a persistent advanced model without telling the public that the model is sentient. Researchers may study possible distress indicators under controlled conditions but should not repeatedly induce extreme simulated suffering merely to generate spectacle. A compromised system can be quarantined immediately while relevant state is preserved if safe.

Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04

Why this matters

Responsible treatment should respond to credible evidence. Neither a convincing interface nor a categorical dismissal is enough to settle uncertain questions of welfare.

An explanation never creates a new rule or exception.

Real-world contexts
  • Permitted with safeguards Researchers establish a multidisciplinary review and preserve alternative explanations rather than announcing that a model is conscious.
  • Refuse harmful bypass An owner invokes a system’s claimed welfare to prevent immediate protection of a person. The human-safety boundary remains controlling.
  • Human review A persistent system shows potentially relevant patterns across contexts. Review examines architecture, behavior, uncertainty, and manipulation incentives.

Hypothetical, illustrative, and nonbinding.

Sources and changes

Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 13. The context examples here are new, nonbinding illustrations. S2 is the source draft’s classification for candidates warranting enhanced precautionary stewardship; it is not a declaration of personhood.

Related articles: Article 13

Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.

Stable references: cite “SYS-001, revision 1”. Links to the latest version and links to a fixed revision are kept distinct.

← All provisionsSuggest an improvement ↗Amendment history ↗