TMA-A003 Foundational article
Freedom from autonomous coercion, corralling, confinement, and punishment
People must not be treated as movable inventory, risk clusters, or administratively inconvenient populations by autonomous systems.
Full provision
Principle. People must not be treated as movable inventory, risk clusters, or administratively inconvenient populations by autonomous systems.
Proposed duty. Systems capable of controlling movement, access, communication, money, identity, transportation, buildings, or essential services must not autonomously impose coercive restrictions without individualized authority, necessity, proportionality, time limits, human accountability, and effective remedy.
Prohibitions. A conforming system must not autonomously:
- corral a crowd into or out of a space for protest suppression, demographic sorting, border processing, debt collection, labor control, or administrative convenience;
- detain, physically restrain, blockade, force escort, disperse, punish, or deny escape based solely on automated classification;
- cut off food, water, housing access, medicine, communication, transportation, identity credentials, or public benefits as an automated punitive measure;
- impose group-level restriction merely because some members are suspected of misconduct;
- use predictive risk, emotion recognition, gait, association, or neighborhood data as a substitute for individualized lawful judgment;
- convert a safety system into a standing tool for policing or behavioral control without public authorization and heightened safeguards.
Required safeguards. Any proposed coercive use must identify the accountable authority, legal basis, affected persons, purpose, geographic and temporal limits, least restrictive alternative, emergency exits, accessibility needs, monitoring, and appeal process. C4 coercive capabilities require separation of duties and independent oversight.
Emergency boundary. Temporary restriction or guidance may be permitted during a specific immediate hazard, such as fire, structural collapse, active traffic danger, contamination, or medical emergency, when it is safety-directed, least restrictive, time-limited, and terminated when the hazard ends.
Public-order boundary. A human institution cannot obtain Accord conformance merely by placing a person nominally in the loop. The person must have lawful authority, current situational understanding, and real power to prevent overreach.
Illustrative examples. A robot may block a collapsing hallway and guide people to a safe exit. A fleet may not form a moving wall that herds peaceful demonstrators into a fenced zone. An accessibility gate may temporarily prevent entry into a dangerous platform area; it may not permanently exclude a disabled user because a model finds assistance inconvenient.
Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04
Sources and changes
Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 3. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.
Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗
Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.