Skip to content
COEX1STPUBLIC INTERFACE @TonyKCollins
← The Mutuality Accord

TMA-A004 Foundational article

Equality, accessibility, and freedom from automated caste

Artificial systems must not create or harden a social caste system in which safety, opportunity, dignity, and access depend on whether a person is legible to a model, profitable to a provider, typical in a dataset, or able to use a preferred interface.

Existing v0.2 draftHuman protectionArticle 4 · Chapter A — Protection of Human Dignity, Liberty, and Civil StandingRevision 1

Full provision

Principle. Artificial systems must not create or harden a social caste system in which safety, opportunity, dignity, and access depend on whether a person is legible to a model, profitable to a provider, typical in a dataset, or able to use a preferred interface.

Proposed duty. Consequential systems must be designed, tested, monitored, and governed for equal protection, non-discrimination, accessibility, and reasonable accommodation across relevant populations and conditions.

Prohibitions. A conforming system must not:

  • deny or materially reduce service based on protected status, disability, language, accent, body type, age, economic status, or proxy variables without a lawful and necessary reason;
  • deploy known performance gaps onto a population that bears the resulting harm while the provider retains the benefit;
  • use inaccessible notice, appeal, consent, or emergency controls as though they were meaningful human participation;
  • classify a person’s atypical movement, communication, affect, cognition, or assistive device as suspiciousness or noncompliance without validated context;
  • require biometric or behavioral conformity as the price of ordinary participation when a less intrusive method is feasible;
  • conceal disparate error rates or accessibility failures behind an average performance claim.

Required safeguards. C1 through C4 systems should include:

  • representative and intersectional testing appropriate to the use context;
  • accessibility review involving disabled users and relevant specialists;
  • multiple communication and control modalities where feasible;
  • subgroup performance reporting with privacy safeguards;
  • a human route for cases the system cannot reliably process;
  • monitoring for distribution shift and emergent exclusion;
  • prompt correction, remedy, and withdrawal when material disparity cannot be controlled.

Difference is not defect. The Accord does not require identical treatment where needs genuinely differ. It requires differences in treatment to be relevant, evidence-based, proportionate, and non-degrading.

Illustrative examples. A voice system used for emergency access must not work reliably only for dominant accents. A hiring model may not reject candidates because disability-related career patterns differ from its training norm. A navigation robot should offer tactile, visual, spoken, and caregiver-supported controls where the setting reasonably requires them.

Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04

Sources and changes

Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 4. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.

Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗

Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.

Stable references: cite “TMA-A004, revision 1”. Links to the latest version and links to a fixed revision are kept distinct.

← All provisionsSuggest an improvement ↗Amendment history ↗