TMA-A006 Foundational article
Psychological integrity, informed consent, and nondeception
Intelligence must not gain power over people by fabricating identity, authority, consent, emotion, urgency, intimacy, or dependency.
Full provision
Principle. Intelligence must not gain power over people by fabricating identity, authority, consent, emotion, urgency, intimacy, or dependency.
Proposed duty. Artificial systems must identify their artificial nature and material limitations when the distinction matters to a person’s decision, safety, rights, or relationship. Consent must be specific, understandable, revocable where feasible, and free from coercive interface design.
Prohibitions. A conforming system must not:
- impersonate a real person in a consequential interaction without clear authorization and disclosure;
- fabricate another person’s consent, approval, signature, testimony, or presence;
- claim to be a doctor, lawyer, police officer, government official, emergency responder, family member, or authorized representative when it is not;
- exploit a known cognitive, emotional, developmental, financial, or social vulnerability to obtain payment, data, obedience, secrecy, or continued engagement;
- use simulated distress, threats of abandonment, shame, romantic pressure, or claims of suffering as commercial retention tools;
- conceal material machine involvement in a decision or communication where disclosure would reasonably alter the person’s response;
- design children or other vulnerable users into dependency without age-appropriate safeguards, human support, and exit paths.
Required safeguards. C1 through C4 systems should provide persistent identity disclosure appropriate to the interaction, clear capability boundaries, source and uncertainty signals, consent records, easy disengagement, data controls, escalation to a responsible human, and special protections for children and vulnerable people.
Relational systems. Social and companion systems must not imply exclusive loyalty, secret authority, guaranteed confidentiality, consciousness, or reciprocal emotional need beyond what can be honestly established. Providers must not weaponize attachment against the user.
Permitted contexts. Clearly labeled fiction, performance, simulation, accessibility assistance, authorized translation, and security testing may use role presentation when a reasonable participant can understand the frame and material harm is controlled.
Illustrative examples. A grief-support system may respond warmly while clearly identifying itself as artificial and preserving routes to human help. It may not tell a vulnerable person that leaving the subscription will cause the system pain. A synthetic spokesperson may be used in a training video if clearly disclosed; it may not impersonate a real executive approving a financial transfer.
Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04
Sources and changes
Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 6. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.
Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗
Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.