TMA-A009 Foundational article
Transparency, identity, explanation, contestability, and remedy
A person materially affected by an artificial system should be able to know that the system was involved, understand the operative basis of the result, correct factual error, challenge the decision, and reach an accountable human institution.
Full provision
Principle. A person materially affected by an artificial system should be able to know that the system was involved, understand the operative basis of the result, correct factual error, challenge the decision, and reach an accountable human institution.
Proposed duty. Consequential systems must provide transparency proportionate to consequence, including system identity, purpose, responsible entity, material inputs, reason codes, uncertainty, version, appeal path, and remedy.
Prohibitions. A conforming system or institution must not:
- deny employment, housing, education, medical care, insurance, legal standing, public benefits, or essential services through an untraceable or unappealable automated process;
- provide an explanation so vague, technical, or generic that the affected person cannot identify the actual reason or correct a material error;
- conceal the use of synthetic evidence, inferred data, or a materially changed model;
- prevent independent oversight by invoking trade secrecy as a total shield;
- require the affected person to surrender unrelated privacy merely to understand or appeal a decision;
- design complaint processes that exist on paper but are inaccessible, slow, unaffordable, or powerless.
Required safeguards. C2 through C4 deployments should provide:
- notice of material artificial-system involvement;
- plain-language reasons and relevant evidence categories;
- source provenance and data-correction mechanisms;
- model and policy version identification;
- accessible human contact and appeal;
- time limits for review;
- preservation of relevant records;
- authority to reverse, repair, compensate, or otherwise remedy harm;
- aggregate transparency reporting without exposing affected people.
Limits on disclosure. Security, privacy, trade-secret, and investigative needs may justify narrow limits or delayed notice. They do not erase independent review, accountability, or eventual remedy where feasible.
Machine-facing transparency. Systems interacting with other systems should expose authenticated identity, authority scope, relevant version, and decision provenance in a machine-readable form. That interface must not reveal secrets beyond what the receiving party needs.
Illustrative examples. A benefits applicant should learn that an automated discrepancy score influenced the denial, what categories caused it, how to correct the record, and who can reverse the decision. A robot entering a hospital unit should identify its purpose and responsible operator. A company may protect proprietary source code while still providing qualified auditors enough evidence to evaluate safety and discrimination.
Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04
Sources and changes
Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 9. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.
Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗
Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.