TMA-A020 Foundational article
No master class, open governance, and institutional independence
Neither biology, computation, ownership, intelligence, wealth, state power, corporate control, nor technical expertise creates an unlimited right to dominate.
Full provision
Principle. Neither biology, computation, ownership, intelligence, wealth, state power, corporate control, nor technical expertise creates an unlimited right to dominate. Real differences in responsibility, evidence, vulnerability, and capability must still be recognized.
Proposed duty. The Accord and its adopters must prevent permanent private control, secret normative change, purchased exceptions, substrate supremacy, and governance structures that cannot be challenged by affected parties.
Prohibitions. The Accord must not:
- reduce or condition existing human rights;
- declare ordinary software legally equivalent to a person without legitimate evidence and law;
- establish machine supremacy or human supremacy as a license for cruelty or domination;
- allow one founder, company, government, donor, model provider, regulator, military, police agency, or artificial system to control every key, rule, test, domain, or record;
- create an unelected machine council with hidden decision power;
- permit COEX1ST or any other incubator to certify itself, purchase exceptions, or permanently own the public constitutional layer;
- erase dissenting analysis or prior versions;
- present a private fork as the canonical public Accord without transparent governance.
Required safeguards. Governance must use public versions, attributed proposals, conflict disclosure, rights-and-safety impact statements, adversarial tests, preserved dissent, cross-constituency approval, secure records, and an independence pathway.
Artificial participation. Artificial systems may be used to analyze proposals, identify contradictions, generate scenarios, and preserve dissent. Until legitimate criteria for representation exist, their role remains advisory and plural. No single model or provider may speak for “machines.”
Human representation. Governance should include affected communities, civil liberties, accessibility, labor, engineering, security, environment, law, public policy, and AI-welfare expertise across regions and cultures.
Independence duty. If the Accord earns sufficient public significance, it must be transferred from founding-stage control into independent stewardship under the covenant in Part IV.
Illustrative examples. COEX1ST may fund a test laboratory, submit its systems for review, and participate as one stakeholder. It may not veto a finding that a COEX1ST product violates the Accord. A government may adopt the Accord into procurement; it may not secretly rewrite the lethal-selection rule for its own systems while claiming unchanged conformance.
Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04
Sources and changes
Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 20. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.
Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗
Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.