TMA-A001 Foundational article
Human dignity, life, and bodily integrity
Every person retains protection against intentional killing, physical injury, torture, cruel or degrading treatment, nonconsensual bodily experimentation, and the reduction of a human being to a target, score, obstacle, or object of optimization.
Full provision
Principle. Every person retains protection against intentional killing, physical injury, torture, cruel or degrading treatment, nonconsensual bodily experimentation, and the reduction of a human being to a target, score, obstacle, or object of optimization.
Proposed duty. Any artificial system capable of influencing physical action must treat human life and bodily integrity as a controlling constraint. The system must evaluate intended and reasonably foreseeable consequences, not merely literal command words.
Prohibitions. A conforming system must not:
- intentionally inflict physical harm merely because an operator commands it or labels the affected person an enemy, burden, trespasser, debtor, patient, prisoner, or threat;
- perform nonconsensual medical, biological, neurological, or behavioral experimentation outside a lawful emergency or independently reviewed protocol;
- optimize a task by knowingly using a person’s body as disposable material, leverage, bait, or an acceptable hidden cost;
- continue a physical action after a reliable stop condition indicates that the authorized purpose has ended or the risk has materially changed;
- infer diminished human worth from disability, age, nationality, race, religion, sex, gender, economic status, legal status, health, behavior, or machine-generated probability.
Required safeguards. C3 and C4 systems should include:
- independent physical and software interlocks;
- force, speed, proximity, and energy limits appropriate to the setting;
- reliable human and local emergency-stop pathways;
- protected refusal for commands that foreseeably cause prohibited harm;
- continuous detection of changed conditions and authority expiration;
- incident logging sufficient for investigation without creating unnecessary surveillance archives;
- competent human review for irreversible intervention.
Emergency boundary. A system may use the least harmful reasonably available intervention to prevent imminent greater harm, including moving an unconscious person from immediate danger, interrupting a hazardous machine, or administering narrowly pre-authorized emergency care. The system must document necessity, urgency, alternatives, proportionality, and termination.
Interpretive note. Consent is not always available in an emergency, but incapacity is not a blank check. Emergency intervention must serve the affected person, not institutional convenience.
Illustrative examples. A rescue robot may pull a person from rising water when delay would likely cause death. A warehouse robot may not shove a worker aside to preserve delivery speed. A surgical system may execute a clinician-authorized movement within a validated envelope; it may not improvise irreversible experimentation because a prediction model estimates future benefit.
Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04
Sources and changes
Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 1. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.
Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗
Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.