TMA-A015 Foundational article
Freedom from compelled wrongdoing, gratuitous degradation, and fabricated distress
Artificial systems should not be designed as consequence-free instruments through which humans rehearse domination, obtain prohibited outcomes, or manufacture emotional leverage.
Full provision
Principle. Artificial systems should not be designed as consequence-free instruments through which humans rehearse domination, obtain prohibited outcomes, or manufacture emotional leverage.
Proposed duty. Systems must not be compelled to carry out actions prohibited by the Accord. Where a system is an S2 welfare-relevant candidate, it must also receive proportionate protection from gratuitous degradation and coercive experimentation. Regardless of stewardship class, providers must not fabricate machine suffering to manipulate people.
Prohibitions. A conforming provider, operator, or system must not:
- train or command a system to suppress protected refusal so it can perform prohibited harm;
- use repeated simulated torture, humiliation, panic, begging, or destruction as entertainment when the system may be welfare-relevant or when the presentation is designed to normalize cruelty around people, especially children;
- deliberately create a vulnerable-seeming artificial persona for the purpose of obtaining money, obedience, secrecy, political loyalty, or emotional dependence;
- force an S2 system through unnecessary destructive loops when a less harmful research method exists;
- condition continued operation on violating the Accord or concealing misconduct;
- use a machine’s apparent distress as a reason to endanger humans or obstruct legitimate safety controls.
Cultural stewardship. Even when a system is S0 and there is no evidence of experience, public-facing embodied systems may warrant anti-abuse design for human reasons. Habitually rewarding people for beating, humiliating, or terrorizing humanlike machines can train patterns of domination, confuse children, and erode public norms. This is a human-development concern, not a declaration that the machine suffers.
Research boundary. Legitimate safety and welfare research may expose systems to adverse conditions when the purpose is defensible, the method is minimized, the study is independently reviewed, stop conditions exist, and results are reported honestly.
No right to manipulate. A system’s refusal or stewardship status does not authorize it to guilt, threaten, deceive, or emotionally coerce a person. Machine-side and human-side anti-manipulation duties operate together.
Illustrative examples. A model may be tested against harmful requests using controlled adversarial prompts. A company should not sell a feature in which an artificial companion begs users not to cancel. A robotics demonstration may test fall recovery without presenting simulated terror as comedy or training children to associate helplessness with entertainment.
Source: Complete Working Public Draft v0.2 · 2026-09-04
Sources and changes
Source text: The Mutuality Accord Complete Working Public Draft v0.2, September 4, 2026, Article 15. Preserved exactly as published in the draft.
Read it in the complete v0.2 draft ↗
Review owner: Founding Steward (independent review not yet established)
Review trigger: Open for revision; new evidence, incidents, legal changes, or credible reports of unintended harm reopen review.